Showing posts with label Class Readings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Class Readings. Show all posts

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Mr. / Mrs. / Miss. / Ms.

When I opened my coursbook a few years ago, I found these four things in the first unit. (Introducing yourself) Some students asked the reason for using three for women. (In Korean, we only have just one for both men and women.) I couldn't explain well at that time.

Why are there two more for women?
Ms. was made later than Mrs. and Miss. Then who made it? For what reason?

It has been more than 50 years (Am I correct?) since it was made by feminists. But many people (men & women both) just use Mrs. Miss., and prefer to use it. Why? ...

I was just wondering..


(GIrl Number Twenty)

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Critical Pedagogy, Critical Teaching, Critical Learning...

Critical Pedagogy in an EFL Teaching Context: An ignis fatuus or an Alternative Approach?

What is critical pedagogy? It may sound like stupid, but I really want to know. While I was reading the article (Critical Pedagogy in an EFL Teaching...), I realized that I had no idea about critical pedagogy or I may have misunderstood the concept. I couldn't focus on the reading since the author briefly decribed the participants and the topics for the lesson.

..22 EFL learners, both male and female, who seem to be diminished and held in minority by the dominant culture of the non-natives were involved. Their ages were between 18 to 29, they were from different educational backgrounds and different cultures. All of them had passed 12 levels of study in language institutions and were participating in a "Chat Course", a free discussion class, to improve their general proficiency and fluency.

Why did this author choose students from only one level which is the highest level in English? At the begining of the article, the author criticized the Audio Lingual Method with two more methods since these are not the method which apply the real outer world to learning. I totally agreed. But as a language teacher, I'm wondering, who uses the Audio Lingual Method for students who are the highest level? Do you? It's very easy to conduct some critical lessons with high level students. Before I took this TESOL course, I'd never tried to bring some sensitive issues into class for my beginner students because I thought it might be impossible, but I did bring many social and sensitive issues into class for the high level students such as gender roles, death penalty, environmental problems, traffic jams in Korea, and more. And many other teachers who teach high level students usually bring some problematic issues for their students. After I took several classes in a graduate school, I'm thinking that I should conduct some critical lessons for my beginner students as well. That's what I'm learning in class. But the author chose high level (actually very high level) students as her participants. Why? For me, it seems like she may have an assumption that usually high level students are capable of doing some ciritical activities. I also want to talk about topics the author chose for the critical lesson.

Topics selected were the following: gender discrimination, cultural invasion and internet filtering, anomie, religion, job opportunity, the society's view of Azad University, prohibition of traditional dress, army service, prohibition of Bandari songs and dance.

I would like to know if there are any teachers who can make very productive discussion class with these topics for beginners. My students are adults, and I know they can discuss these things in their mother tongue, but I'm not sure about in English. Will they enjoy my class if I bring these topics? Or will they complain to my boss about my lesson because it's too difficult? Why all topics are all about problems? Can't we make critical lesson without talking about problems, issues, and something political? I enjoyed the activity when professor showed some ads (maybe in class last semester) and let us think of the advertiser, targets, and the messages. I also enjoyed the activity when he showed a picture (in SLA class) and let us guess the meaning of the picture (which was drown by an ape). I also very much enjoyed when my high school teacher let us guess the meaning of metaphors in poetry. As a teacher, I enjoyed when my students gave a lot of interesting opinions about their coursebook, and when they made their own (cute, interesting) activites. I also enjoyed when my students made their dream neighborhood and explained the reason why they think it's good. Aren't these activites critical? These are the ones that I cannot connect with real world? I read many readings in class, and many of them talk about racism, feminism, political issues, power, problems... Why do we think of political or social problems first when we think of critical pedgogy?
Critical learning means finding problems only? What is the real purpose for the critical pedagogy?

(I've read a book "Flowers for Algernon". This is about the man who was metally challenged and then became a genius after a special experiment and finally became mentally challenged again. When he was not smart, he was happy and he thought every person around him was trustful. He thought the world was beautiful. And then he became a genius. He realized that the world is not good. The people were all using him because he was stupid. He had many things to solve and to think about. He became so obsessed. Because the experiment had a critical problem, he became stupid again. He started to smile. He was happy. He liked everyone around him.)

Monday, April 11, 2011

Who make a good classroom? (better classroom)

Teachers? Students? or others?

banking education
transmission of knowledge

The same problems, and the similar solutions.

1. What changes do we need in Korean education system to make the classes as a leaner-centered (problem posing class)?
2. How can teachers make all the students involved in class? How can teachers know individual student's own interest? What is the best way?
3. What is the best way to assess the students in a learner-centered class (problem posing class)?
4. What kinds of activities are suitable to make a problem posing class in EFL classroom?

Monday, April 4, 2011

Literacy

Literacy and the Literacy Myth: From Plato to Freire

When I saw the word 'literacy' at first in a graduate school, I searched the dictionary. In English it means 'the ability to read and write', and in Korean it also means 'the ability to read and write'. In a English-Korean dictionary, it literally says like that in Korean, which means we do not have any particular word for 'literacy'. 'Literacy' seems to be very important for many countries like USA and Eropean countries. Many people think it's been playing very significant roles in a lot of fields like sicientific civilization, modern civilization, liberty, democratic society.... (It may be just myth like someone said..)

If it's that important, why do we have no word for 'literacy'? Korean people don't care for 'literacy'? What is literacy in Korean? What does that mean to us? How has the 'literacy' influenced Korean society?

.... Let's say a computer is broken. A person asks some help to his friends or family. Or he could call the A/S center and ask some help.  B person reads the instruction carefully and tries to fix the computer by following the instructions there. ... Anyway both fixed the computer. Which one is more intelligent?

'Literacy' seems to be difficult to define. In a English dictionary, it means 'the ability to read and write' but many people think it's more than it.

Then,
What is literacy?
Why is it important?
If there are certain age when chidren can get a 'literacy', what should we do for them? How can we help them? What are the roles of parents, schools, and so on?

Monday, March 28, 2011

Pedagogy of the oppressed

Freire's banking concept of education sounds interesting.

... Education becomes an act of depositing...

This reminds me of Korean education system. In the past, I mean, really long time ago, Korean education wasn't like a banking model. What makes the cram schools? I think after the Japanese colonial era, Korea was extremely poor. To be developed, cramming teaching method might be effective, and yes, Korea has been developed rapidly. What about now?
We all know that there should be some changes in Korean education. We all agree there are many problems in it. We all think students should be more than receivers or listeners. Then why does Korean education system stay almost the same? What are the reasons or obstacles to hamper the changes?

... Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction...
... The banking approach to adult education, for example, will never propose to students that they critically consider reality....
... The banking system concept does not admit to such partnership...
... The teacher is no longer merely the one who teachers, but one who is himself taught in dialogue with the students, who in turn while being taught also teach...
... In this way, the problem-posing educator constantly re-forms his reflections in the reflection of the students....
... In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves...

Great sentences...
-Who is the ideal teacher in problem-posing education?
-What are the key features of the ideal teacher?
-Who are the ideal students in problem-posing education?
-What are the key feature of the ideal student?
-Who can make problem posing education? Teachers? Students? Government people? People who make the text books? Who are the opperessor in Korean education?

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Culture Industry

... The function of the culture industry is therefore, ultimately, to organize leisure time in the same way as industrialization has organized work time......

My thoughts
In Korea, there is a big thing for people, that is English. Many parents spend a lot of money on English education for their children. English kindergardens became very popular. Many university students go abroad to study English like following the fashion trend. More business people attend an English class because they think they have to.
I always ask the reason why they want to study English at the first time in class. I'm surprised to hear that so many people answer they study English because other people do. Sometimes I'm wondering... what makes people study English here in Korea?

Lesson Plans.... & The Frankfurt School

Lesson Plans From the Outer Limits: Unauthorized Methods

My questions
1. How can teachers in Korea have the empowerment for their own classes?
2. How can be a criticial teacher?
3. If teachers have their own empowerment for their class, what are the benefits for the students?

The Frankfurt School

My questions
1. How can we make the mass culture be more pure?
2. Does the mass culture have only negative effects?
3. What is high culture and what is low culture? What makes the difference?

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Engaging students in dialogue and critical reflection

... During the dialogical engagement between teacher and students and students themselves, the life experiences of students are emphasized, through which the students begin to recognize each other as sources of knowledge...
...students are engaged in the decision-making process in class...

My response

I'm sure that critical approach is very important not only in a language class, but in other classes. It's always lovely to hear some unexpected or unique thoughts or ideas from students and have some discussions and debates with them. I love to be asked even though I can't answer to every single question from my student. I don't like to give one straight answer to my student. I like to think together. I'd like them to share their ideas or thoughts each other.

My concern, however, is this; do we have to make our class critical even for beginners? If so, is it possible to teach grammar, vocabulary, and simple structures with a critical approach? Do we have to consider a critical approach even when teaching grammar and vocabulary?
If I teach some vocabualry and some grammar structures and after that if I conduct activites which are critical, can I say I'm using a critical approach in my class?

As a critical approach, I can think of dicussions or debates usually. It is almost impossible to make my students to have some discussions or debates in English. My students even have problems with answering to very simple questions like 'What did you do last weekend?' or 'What are your hobbies?'.
In this case, what kind of activites can I use for my students to engage them in dialogue and critical reflection?

English Education in South Korea

English education and teacher education in South Korea - Seongja Jo

My questions
1. If English is Englishes, what kind of English do teachers have to teach in Korea?
2. How can teachers enhance students' English skill through a public education system?
3. Who are the qualified English teachers in Korea?
4. How can we enhance the teacher training system in Korea?
5. Is the co-teaching with native speakers the best way to improve students communicative competence & performance?

Indigenous Critical Traditions for TEFL? A Historical and Comparative Perspective in the Case of Korea - Hyunjung Shin & Graham Crookes

My questions
1. How do teachers make the general English class critical?
2. Is it possible to make English class critical for beginners?
3. What kind of activities can teachers conduct for beginners to make a critical class?